1 Technical Comparison Between Closed-Cooling Towers and Open-Cooling Towers
Technical Route Comparison
|
No |
Comparison Item |
Closed-Cooling System |
Open-Cooling System |
|
1 |
Engineering Site Photo |
|
|
|
2 |
Cooling Method |
Indirect heat exchange: Under the forced action of fans, the heat of the fluid inside the tubes is dissipated by the evaporation of the water film outside the heat exchange tubes. |
Direct heat exchange: Circulating water is sprayed onto PVC fill packs to increase the contact area between water and air, and cooling is performed under the forced action of fans. |
|
3 |
Main Heat Exchange Components |
S30408 stainless steel heat exchange tubes |
PVC fill packs |
|
4 |
Heat Exchange Performance |
Heat exchange is conducted via metal heat exchange tubes, ensuring stable heat exchange performance at all times. |
When the fill packs are contaminated by air and water, the air duct becomes blocked, the fill packs are damaged, and their cooling capacity decreases—resulting in reduced overall heat exchange performance. |
|
5 |
Water Quality |
Demineralized water remains in a closed state and does not contact the outside. This avoids contamination of the cooled medium and equipment caused by the contact between the medium and air. |
Demineralized water contacts air and is easily exposed to sunlight. The water is prone to being affected by ambient air, sunlight, and sand and dust, which may cause blockage and corrosion of equipment and pipelines. |
|
6 |
Winter Operation Conditions, Anti-Freezing Performance & Measures |
When the ambient temperature is low, the spray water outside the tubes can be stopped to realize dry operation, achieving energy conservation and anti-freezing purposes. |
When the ambient temperature is low, the contact surface between water and air may experience severe freezing at the air inlet and fill packs due to low temperatures. This causes increased static pressure inside the tower, leading to vibration of fans and the tower body. |
|
7 |
Operation & Maintenance |
With proper control of spray water quality, there is almost no need to maintain heat exchange components. Operation and maintenance are simple, and online cleaning (without shutting down the unit) is feasible. |
When the ambient temperature is low, the contact surface between water and air may experience severe freezing at the air inlet and fill packs due to low temperatures. This causes increased static pressure inside the tower, leading to vibration of fans and the tower body. When fill packs are blocked due to contamination by air and water, cleaning and replacement are particularly difficult and require skilled workers. Waste fill packs need to be disposed of in an environmentally friendly manner, requiring a large construction area. Fill packs are replaced every 2–3 years on average, resulting in high operating costs. |
|
8 |
Environmental Adaptability |
Suitable for various environmental conditions, widely used in both northern and southern regions—especially in environments with poor air quality and water quality indicators, such as heavy industries including metallurgy, petroleum, electric power, and chemical engineering. |
Open-cooling towers are suitable for environments with good air quality and water quality indicators, such as refrigeration systems in urban central air conditioning, food, beer, and pharmaceutical factories, as well as light industries. |
|
9 |
Engineering Construction |
The equipment is supplied as an integral skid-mounted unit, requiring only strip foundations for support. The layout is flexible (e.g., can be installed on the roof of pump rooms), with a short construction period. |
Requires a large amount of civil engineering work, including the construction of suction forebays and water storage tanks. Cooling towers and pump rooms need to be arranged separately, resulting in a long on-site construction period. |
|
10 |
Service Life |
The outer protective structure, support structure, and heat exchange components are all made of metal materials, featuring high structural strength and a long service life. |
The outer protective structure, internal tower components, and heat exchange components are made of FRP (fiberglass-reinforced plastic) or PVC materials, featuring low mechanical strength and a short service life. |
|
11 |
System Stability |
The closed circulating water system is equipped with automatic pressure stabilization and degassing equipment. All pipelines and equipment are filled with water (no air), so sudden startup or shutdown of pumps will not cause impact on equipment and pipelines. |
Operation requires preventing impact on equipment and pipelines caused by sudden startup or shutdown of pumps. |
|
12 |
Head of Main Circulation Pump |
The head of the closed circulating system only needs to overcome equipment pressure loss and along-the-way pipeline pressure loss, so the power of the main circulation pump is relatively small. |
In addition to overcoming equipment pressure loss and along-the-way pipeline pressure loss, the open-cooling system also needs to consider the pressure head required for height difference—resulting in higher power of the main circulation pump. |
1.1.1 Technical Parameter Comparison (2000 m³/h Circulating Water)
|
No. |
Item |
Unit |
Closed-Circulating System |
Open-Circulating System |
Remarks |
|
1 |
Design Wet-Bulb Temperature |
℃ |
22 |
22 |
|
|
2 |
Circulating Water Flow |
m³/h |
2000 |
2000 |
|
|
3 |
Inlet Water Temperature |
℃ |
48 |
48 |
|
|
4 |
Outlet Water Temperature |
℃ |
33 |
33 |
|
|
5 |
Calculated Heat Dissipation |
kW |
34890 |
34890 |
|
|
6 |
Axial Fan Power |
kW |
11×12 |
132×2 |
|
|
7 |
Spray Pump Quantity & Power |
kW |
5.5×8 |
/ |
|
|
8 |
Main Circulation Pump Power |
kW |
160 |
250 |
|
|
9 |
Maximum Water Consumption |
t/h |
51.72 |
57.86 |
|
|
10 |
Average Water Consumption |
t/h |
36.21 |
52.07 |
|
|
11 |
Total Consumed Shaft Power |
kW |
268.8 |
411.2 |
Calculated based on 0.8 times the nameplate power |
|
12 |
Equipment Floor Area |
m |
20×9 |
26.7×16.4 |
|
|
13 |
Annual Water Cost |
USD |
15300 |
22000 |
|
|
14 |
Annual Electricity Cost |
USD |
11360 |
17370 |
|
|
15 |
Circulating Water Treatment Cost |
USD |
324 |
1760 |
|
|
16 |
Fill Pack Replacement Cost |
USD |
/ |
535 |
Amortized annually over a 3-year cycle |
|
17 |
Annual Operating Cost |
USD |
26980 |
41660 |
|
|
18 |
Initial Investment Estimate |
USD |
33100 |
28870 |
Including equipment and main circulation system |
|
19 |
Annual Fixed Cost |
USD |
4626 |
4046 |
= Total investment × 0.14 annual allocation rate |
|
20 |
Annual Total Cost |
USD |
31606 |
45706 |
= Annual operating cost + Annual fixed cost |
|
21 |
Scheme Ranking (Superiority) |
– |
1 |
2 |
|
Notes:
1.The economic comparison of schemes adopts the minimum annual total cost method, i.e., Annual Operating Cost + Annual Fixed Cost.
2.Annual operating hours are calculated based on 7,500 hours.
3.Water price: 4 RMB/t; Electricity price: 0.4 RMB/kWh.
4.The closed-cooling tower is installed on the roof of the pump room, while the open-cooling tower is installed on the ground.